Northwest Kiteboarding
Forum | Classifieds | Lost & Found | CGKA | Industry | Sensors | Forecast | Spots | Seattle | Decals | RSS | Facebook

Events | Photos | Search | Register | Profile | Log in to check your messages | Log in 

High wind veteran, small kite novice: 4m questions

 
Post new topic   Reply to topic    Northwest Kiteboarding -> Gorge / Portland / Oregon Coast
previous topic :: next topic  
Author Message
bfb38

Since 02 Sep 2016
43 Posts

 



PostTue Nov 10, 20 6:31 am    High wind veteran, small kite novice: 4m questions Reply with quote

I'm in the market for a 4/5m to complement my 6,8,11m neos, batwing/larger dwarfcraft, and surfboard. I'd use it mostly for foiling but also occasionally on the surfboard, which I'm usually on and would likely continue to be on from ~21/22kn and up if there's any sort of organization to the swell/chop where I am. So I'm looking at pretty niche use: strong wind with crummy chop or really strong wind regardless.

I'm interested in a single strut, partly for the sake of travel and partly because I've heard a lot of 3 strut smaller kites backstall frequently.

At the moment I use my 6m if at all possible while foiling and above 24kn on my surfboard. I've spent a lot of time on a 5m neo, the smallest I've flown, and loved it, but am considering the range I could gain going to 4m. I also demoed the 5m ufo at Rufus a few weeks ago and loved it (Thanks, Jon), but perhaps naively want to retain some functionality for jumping/riding swell on the surfboard. I can only remember 2 days ever when I couldn't use my 6m(Both in South Africa), but have had plenty of days when I'm stacked and needed to think before downlooping.

I likely won't have a chance to demo anything before I buy so I'm looking for input. What do you like? Is a single strut going to fold in half at 40kn? What kind of ranges have you worked out for your smallest? Is a 4-6 quiver gap annoying? Is it worth it at all? Would I be better off investing in other stuff like a foil/single strut bigger kite, less crummy foil setup, or my IRA?

Thanks for weighing in

View user's profile Send private message
phill

Since 26 May 2016
32 Posts

 



PostTue Nov 10, 20 9:43 am    High wind veteran, small kite novice: 4m questions Reply with quote

I too ride a 6M Neo almost by default when foiling , however 25knots and above my 2020 4M Neo calms everything down.

Of course it would be nice to fill in a 5m as well , but the 4M is a stable fit.
I have never had any issues with back stalling with it.

View user's profile Send private message
user124

Since 02 Aug 2012
351 Posts
Portland
Obsessed



PostTue Nov 10, 20 12:45 pm     Reply with quote

I think a 4-6m gap would be too much. I have drifters in 4/5/7/9 and often wish I had a 6m. But maybe I'm just picky. It's often said though that the gap between sizes should be smaller in smaller sizes because the percent increase in surface area of your kite is similar going from say a 4-5 and 8-10. Makes sense to me.

Also, I'm not sure if number of strut always predicts backstall. Drifters are hard to backstall, at least compared to SST, and are 3 strut. I'm with you on the UFO - they look like great foiling kites but I'm not ready to give up my surfboards and I don't want another quiver of foil-specific kits.

View user's profile Send private message
a.benjamin76

Since 27 Jul 2017
70 Posts

 



PostTue Nov 10, 20 2:55 pm    Strut it up Reply with quote

If you're kiting in 4m weather, the wind is usually honking somewhere between 35 and 60. In my humble opinion, your kite won't hindenberg or stall in those conditions and you want something rock solid in the sky that can handle strong gusts. My tiny kites are all 5 strutters for this reason. Who cares about the extra kite weight when the wind is that strong. I'll take stability and wide wind range (more struts) any day over these light weight feather kites. Not to mention, a heavier kite is usually stronger and thicker built to withstand stronger conditions. A single strutter or strutless kite may have you overpowered very quickly as soon as you hit some gusts and could damage easier. Light kites are for light wind.

View user's profile Send private message
bigjohn

Since 13 Mar 2012
565 Posts

Addicted



PostTue Nov 10, 20 5:25 pm    Re: Strut it up Reply with quote

Big wind = lots of struts and big leading edges.... unless you're mamann

You may want to pm mamann as he seems to make tiny little single struts work in all conditions. He does it with a foil though, not a surfboard.

_________________
Kiting starts at 40MPH

View user's profile Send private message
bfb38

Since 02 Sep 2016
43 Posts

 



PostWed Nov 11, 20 6:53 am    Re: Strut it up Reply with quote

a.benjamin76 wrote:
If you're kiting in 4m weather, the wind is usually honking somewhere between 35 and 60. In my humble opinion, your kite won't hindenberg or stall in those conditions and you want something rock solid in the sky that can handle strong gusts. My tiny kites are all 5 strutters for this reason. Who cares about the extra kite weight when the wind is that strong. I'll take stability and wide wind range (more struts) any day over these light weight feather kites. Not to mention, a heavier kite is usually stronger and thicker built to withstand stronger conditions. A single strutter or strutless kite may have you overpowered very quickly as soon as you hit some gusts and could damage easier. Light kites are for light wind.


For what it's worth, and I'm guessing here, I'd probably be foiling on a 4m foiling in low 20kns, which is where I start to feel plenty(read "too much") power on my 6m. This is of course unless the gap between the two would leave me lost. I'm happy riding super lightly-powered while foiling and actually prefer the freedom to loop with impunity.

After a session just last night in gusts and rather horrible chop I was on my surfboard only because my 6m would have been too much for foiling. I'm pretty set on pursuing something smaller at this point.

View user's profile Send private message
ldhr

Since 21 Jul 2009
1311 Posts
Hood River
XTreme Poster



PostWed Nov 11, 20 7:24 am     Reply with quote

how much do you weigh?
When using a 4m to foil, when working the kite back and forth to waterstart in lulls.... - it will taco if you weigh more than 170.
The 5m Neo is a great kite. You'll use it a lot (foil and surfboard).
The 4m Slingshot Ghost is also a great kite for foil.

The reduction in size from 10 to 8 is 20%
The reduction in size from 6 to 4 is 33%. That's a big gap.
That's why a lot of gorge foilers have a quiver of 4,5,6 or 4,5,7.

View user's profile Send private message
bfb38

Since 02 Sep 2016
43 Posts

 



PostWed Nov 11, 20 2:55 pm     Reply with quote

ldhr wrote:
how much do you weigh?
When using a 4m to foil, when working the kite back and forth to waterstart in lulls.... - it will taco if you weigh more than 170.
The 5m Neo is a great kite. You'll use it a lot (foil and surfboard).
The 4m Slingshot Ghost is also a great kite for foil.

The reduction in size from 10 to 8 is 20%
The reduction in size from 6 to 4 is 33%. That's a big gap.
That's why a lot of gorge foilers have a quiver of 4,5,6 or 4,5,7.


That's helpful beta about the weight. I weigh 185 in my birthday suit.
Overpowered on the 6m again today in low 20smph gusting mid 20s and that's in warm (barely) tropical wind

View user's profile Send private message
dcfordo

Since 19 May 2011
56 Posts
The Dalles
 



PostMon Nov 16, 20 6:09 pm    4m ghost Reply with quote

I have a 4m ghost, that I got mainly for my smaller wife and son to use, for which it has been absolutely great.

I have used it a bit myself for foiling. It worked reasonably but even on a foil, when I flew the kite aggressively, it deformed easily. I never tried it, but I think it would be a terrible kite for a surfboard in high wind. Especially for you, since I weigh less than you at #160.

View user's profile Send private message
purdyd

Since 27 Nov 2006
37 Posts

 



PostWed Nov 18, 20 2:41 pm     Reply with quote

Quote:
I likely won't have a chance to demo anything before I buy so I'm looking for input. What do you like? Is a single strut going to fold in half at 40kn? What kind of ranges have you worked out for your smallest? Is a 4-6 quiver gap annoying? Is it worth it at all? Would I be better off investing in other stuff like a foil/single strut bigger kite, less crummy foil setup, or my IRA?


I dint think a single strut kite will fold in half at 40 knots. I think that is more about the leading edge thickness and pressure and not the # of struts.

My 4m ghost I admit I have not had it out in 40 knots seems fine as does my 3m ufo. I don’t notice any folding of those kites.

I would not like a 6-4 meter gap. I think that is a huge gap and the 5m is a great size for foiling.

I’d get the 5m neo and you know you will use that foiling and even on your surfboard.

I think the small kites feel like they are prone to stall because bar sheeting changes the kite angle more than on their larger brethren.

I’d probably upgrade your foil and then board in that order.

And then consider some small foil specific small kites.

Hopefully slingshot will come out with a 4m ufo next year.

Then you could have 5,4,3 m no strut kites which would be more of an extension of your quiver instead of being duplicates.


Good luck!

View user's profile Send private message
Post new topic   Reply to topic    Northwest Kiteboarding -> Gorge / Portland / Oregon Coast All times are GMT - 8 Hours
Page 1 of 1

 
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You can attach files in this forum
You can download files in this forum